Guards! Guards! (1990)
Finished: 3/21/15
There have not been noble dragons in Ankh Morpork for as long as anyone can remember, and the general consensus is that they are extinct. Witnesses are surprised, then, to see something flying over the city and a group of people turned to ash. The City Guard, including Captain Vimes and new dwarf recruit Carrot, must find the dragon and help save the city.
From about the third book on, each Discworld volume has been better than the last, and this one takes another leap forward. I’ve heard many times that the City Guard books are the best of the series, and now I’m looking forward to reading more. What I particularly liked here is that there has been enough groundwork set by the previous books that the Discworld now feels lived-in and real. That foundation is essential to building a strong plot because now we can look at both character details and larger interactions and consequences instead of having to constantly stop and say “oh I forgot to mention, the librarian is an orangutan.”
BBC Big Read Ranking: 69/200
As there are at least another 10 Discworld books on the list, I’ll talk about the ranking of this book and the series as a whole here, then compare within the series in the future.
Terry Pratchett is the most represented author on the Big Read list, with 15 books in the top 100. None of them crack the top 50, though—this one falls just below Mort (#65) and immediately below Good Omens (#68). This feels kind of odd to me. If he’s such a popular author, how come none of the books rank higher? I wonder if it’s because it’s hard to pick a favorite. If participants had been allowed to select the Discworld series as one title, I’m sure it would have ended up much higher in the list. Maybe, like Good Omens, it’s a matter of time—if the vote were repeated today, would Discworld books be higher? In the end, I think this ranking is about right for this book, but the rankings as a whole don’t seem to show how beloved the series is.